On one occasion, I remember discussing with one of my co-workers about my hope that the Detroit Lions would draft Vernon Gholston.

(Sure am glad that didn’t happen….)

I was naive enough to believe that predicting the draft was rather straightforward. You know, analyze team needs, then select the best player at a position of great need.

It was a long time ago….

Years later, sitting here at my computer, I am armed with greater experience, and tons more knowledge about the inner workings of the draft. Yet, I feel that the more I learn, the more I realize how delightfully unpredictable the whole process can be.

I also know that the daunting task of analyzing all 32 NFL teams for a mock draft can cause subtle details to be overlooked. Allow me to elaborate more on this concept.

1. The Carolina Panthers have been linked to both Cam Newton and Blaine Gabbert for quite some time. Indeed, it is readily apparent that neophyte quarterback Jimmy Clausen struggled to command the Panthers offense last season. Largely for that reason, Carolina now sits atop the draft, where quarterbacks seem to be in high demand.

However, I wrote recently about how no team over the last 20 years has ever selected a 1^st round QB after selected one in the 1^st or 2^nd round the previous year.

If quarterback is not the answer, consider providing a receiving target like A.J. Green, or try upgrading the defensive line with arguably the best player in the draft, Marcell Dareus.

2. The San Francisco 49ers hired Jim Harbaugh out of Stanford to replace Mike Singletary as head coach. At Stanford, Harbaugh emphatically stated that he wanted “scholar-athletes” on his football team. If those words can be taken at face value, it suggests that he wants more than just high football I.Q. Perhaps a test like the Wonderlic  carries weight with Harbaugh and his staff.

Largely for this reason, I find talk about Patrick Peterson going to San Fran seems awfully far-fetched. I’d be shocked if he slipped that far, and his abnormally low Wonderlic could be a substantial red flag to Harbaugh.

Then, who might the 49ers be after?  Prince Amukamara or J.J. Watt seem to be prime candidates.

3. The Dallas Cowboys have not left any stone unturned with regards to scouting the major offensive tackle prospects. Reports have even suggested that Dallas is the team that has shown the most interest in USC tackle Tyron Smith.

I’m just not buying the hype. I do agree that Dallas needs help along the offensive front, but not with the 9^th pick. I’ve watched Tyron Smith, and here is what I see on tape:

An ideal zone-blocking tackle who can effectively latch and turn his opponent with his good quickness. Didn’t show the ability to consistently drive block, and would take time to adjust to a man blocking scheme.

Smith’s value will be at its highest in a zone blocking scheme such as the one that Houston or Washington runs. But I simply do not believe he carries that grade for the Dallas Cowboys. They run the type of man blocking scheme that requires big nasties. Tyron Smith would be among the smallest members of that front. Take a glance at some of the OT’s the Cowboys have employed in the recent past. It is clear that Smith (in red) would be substantially smaller than all the others on the list:

Marc Colombo            6-8/ 320

Leonard Davis             6-6/ 355

Doug Free                      6-6/ 320

Flozell Adams              6-7/ 338

Sam Young                    6-8/ 322

Alex Barron                  6-8/ 316

Tyron Smith                 6-5/ 310

If Dallas is dead set on taking a tackle at 9, I suspect that either Anthony Castonzo or Nate Solder would look the part. Prince Amukamara is a popular pick, if he makes it past the 49ers. And J.J. Watt needs to be in the discussion, too. He doesn’t get the attention from the media, but all I can say is watch him line up against Ohio State and sack Terrelle Pryor 3 times. Need I say more?

4. Like Dallas, the Detroit Lions are another team that utilizes the man blocking scheme. If they were to select Tyron Smith at 13, I’d have a tough time wrapping my brain around that decision. Castonzo and Solder could figure into Detroit’s plans if they could trade back a few spots. But it ultimately boils down to how much they like the progress that Jason Fox has made this past season. He was brought in as a developmental guy who might be able to take over for Jeff Backus sooner or later.

Most of the prospects Detroit has brought in figure to be mid-first rounders. It seems they are poised to trade down to get greater value for their targets. If they can’t, bolstering the defensive line with a prospect like Aldon Smith or Cameron Jordan would give Detroit more options once Kyle Vanden Bosch hangs up his cleats. Cornerback and linebacker are severe needs, but there are some excellent values in the 2^nd and 3^rd rounds (Ras I-Dowling, Bruce Carter, Mason Foster).

I can certainly understand that some people will not agree with my method of thinking. If you’re one of those people, leave your thoughts, and I’ll give you my feedback!

Please click here (Bill Walsh Draft Blueprints) to view the attachment of the complete study on Walsh’s draft history.

Few coaches can boast that they invented the offense that they run. San Francisco 49ers coach Bill Walsh could claim such high praise. During his tenure in the Golden State, he  invented the West Coast offensive scheme, winning three Superbowls on his way to the Hall of Fame.

I want to note Walsh’s supreme understanding of the intricacies of the NFL Draft. This knowledge allowed him to produce some of the richest draft classes in history. His most noteworthy draft came in 1986, a pivotal year in the franchise.  In that year, Walsh desperately needed to replenish his roster, and replenish the roster he did, indeed.  By masterfully trading for additional picks, Walsh ended up with 13 draft selections, and made all of them count. The players acquired that year allowed San Francisco to maintain league dominance for many more years. For this reason, the 49ers’ 1986 draft will go down as one of the greatest of all time.

CBSsports.com and NFL.com provided the raw data for this study.

10. San Francisco 49ers

-Matthew Stafford (QB/Georgia)

NFL.com

To most of you, seeing Stafford here may not make much sense. But if Detroit passes on him, the next team that legitimately could justify selecting a quarterback is San Francisco. They drafted Alex Smith with the 1st overall pick in 200, but he has struggled mightily thus far. Shaun Hill showed some spark this year, but obviously he is not the clear starter or the 49ers wouldn’t have tried to sign Kurt Warner.

Stafford offers great value at the 10th spot. His arm strength is superb, and he really impressed teams with his interviewing skills during the combine. The ideal situation for him would be to sit behind Shaun Hill and/or Alex Smith until he is ready to step in as the starter.

Note: although I really like Mark Sanchez, I think there isn’t enough film to evaluate him properly. He is a more risky pick, so Stafford gets the nod.

-Rey Maualuga (ILB/USC)

NFL.com

Think of how awesome a force the 49ers would have if they chose Rey Maualuga to play alongside Patrick Willis. I think teams would be soiling their uniforms just thinking about running the ball up the middle!  Coach Singletary, a former Bears linebacker could appreciate having a player of Maualuga’s caliber. Now, Takeo Spikes is 34 years old, and an infusion of youth behind him (or in front) would be a welcome addition. I could see Mike Singletary attempt to build a defense as ferocious as the ones he was a part of. And make no mistake, bringing in Maualuga would be a huge step in that direction.

-Brian Cushing (OLB/USC)

NFL.com

A tough, hardworking, versatile player, Brian Cushing is the kind of complete football player that Singletary wants. Current OLB Manny Lawson hasn’t been very productive (3 sacks), so the 49ers should be looking for an upgrade on the right side.

Cushing is one of the more ready outside linebackers in this class. He is much farther along in pass coverage than any of the converted linebackers would be. And since Aaron Maybin isn’t valued this highly in my opinion, then Cushing is the target.

-Andre Smith (LT/Alabama)

NFL.com

This is maybe a bit too early to consider Andre Smith, but he would really help establish the right side of the 49ers line. Jonas Jennings was a poor right tackle, and unfortunately Joe Staley can’t play both tackle spots simultaneously.

Smith is an excellent run blocker and actually would make an excellent right tackle, even though he played on the left side in college. After he showed up to the combine out of shape, his stock took a hit. But there is no question about his abilities. As the winner of the Outlander trophy, he joins the likes of men like Joe Thomas, Jonathan Ogden, Chris Samuels, and Orlando Pace.

San Francisco is in dire need of offensive line help (allowed 55 sacks). They allowed more sacks than any other team in the league. The  only reason I have Smith here because the top 3 left tackles will probably be gone by this pick. The 49ers may feel they can choose a better play now, and address the line after round 1.

Next on the clock: Buffalo Bills

Keep voting so we can compare the fan picks with my own! At the end of my completed mock draft I will show all the results. Great job so far.

[poll id="12"]